Why Screen Readers Experience Websites Differently

When designing a website, it is easy to assume that all users experience it visually, scanning menus, banners, sidebars, and interactive elements. For people who rely on screen readers, a website is not a spatial layout but a linear document.

The difference in perception can make or break a site’s accessibility. Without the right structure in place, navigation becomes confusing and frustrating. Designing with accessibility in mind improves the experience for screen reader users and creates websites that are more usable for everyone.

In this article, we will explore how they work, why accessibility matters in web design, and the practical steps you can take to build inclusive, well-structured websites.

What is a Screen Reader? 

A screen reader is a type of assistive technology that converts digital text into speech or braille. It allows people with visual impairments to navigate websites, applications, and documents by reading content aloud or sending it to a braille display.

Rather than interpreting a page visually, screen readers follow the underlying code, moving through headings, links, lists, and other elements in a set order. The quality of that experience depends on how well a website is structured, which is why accessibility is such an important part of web design.

How Do Screen Readers Work?

Screen readers process the code behind a web page and present it as spoken feedback or on a reader display, such as a refreshable braille device. Instead of moving visually through menus and layouts, users navigate step by step using the keyboard. Headings, lists, links, and landmarks act as signposts, allowing quick jumps to different parts of a page.

When a website is built with proper semantic HTML, the reading order makes sense and screen reader users can move efficiently between sections. If the structure is missing or inconsistent, navigation becomes slow and frustrating, since the screen reader will read everything in sequence without context.

To make sure your site stays accessible over time, explore our Website Accessibility Monitoring service.

Why Screen Reader Accessibility is Essential for Web Design

Designing with accessibility in mind ensures that people who rely on screen readers can navigate and use a website effectively. Without this focus, essential features such as menus, buttons, and forms may be unusable, excluding visitors who depend on assistive technology.

Accessibility also improves the overall quality of a site. A well-structured page is easier to maintain, performs better in search engines, and provides a smoother experience for mobile and voice-controlled browsing. Prioritising accessibility from the start creates digital spaces that are more inclusive, usable, and sustainable.

Find out more in our Accessibility in the Definition of Done guide which explains how to make accessibility part of every release.

Building Websites with Semantic HTML

Since screen reader users rely on a document-like reading order, web pages must be built with proper semantic markup. Semantic HTML gives structure and meaning to content, helping assistive technologies understand how different parts of a page relate to one another. A strong foundation not only improves accessibility but also supports consistency, maintainability, and search engine performance.

To create a website that works for everyone, keep these practices in mind:

  • Headings must follow a logical structure – Skipping heading levels or using them purely for styling disrupts navigation.

  • Landmarks should be clearly defined – Regions such as navigation, main content, and footers should be identified using appropriate HTML elements (e.g., <nav>, <main>, <footer>).

  • Interactive elements must be coded correctly – Links, buttons, and form fields should use proper HTML elements rather than generic <div> or <span> tags.

  • Dynamic content should be made accessible – Elements like carousels, accordions, and pop-ups need ARIA roles and keyboard support to ensure screen reader users can interact with them.

For practical guidance on this, read our Importance of Landmarks for Screen Reader Users article.

Common Accessibility Pitfalls for Screen Reader Users

Even when a site looks polished and functions well for sighted visitors, accessibility barriers can remain hidden. These issues often surface only when tested with assistive technology, and they can quickly disrupt the experience of screen reader users. Small coding oversights, missing labels, or poor structural choices can make an otherwise usable site frustrating or even impossible to navigate.

Some of the most common pitfalls include:

  • Content is visually positioned with CSS but doesn’t follow a meaningful order in the HTML.

  • Important elements (like a checkout button) are hidden from assistive technology due to incorrect ARIA attributes.

  • Navigation menus lack structure, forcing users to listen to an entire block of text instead of quickly jumping to relevant sections.

  • Forms lack accessible labels, leaving screen reader users guessing what to enter in each field.

If these issues sound familiar, our Remediation Consulting service can help you identify and fix accessibility barriers so your site works for every user.

Testing Websites for Screen Reader Accessibility

Building an accessible site is only the first step. Regular testing ensures that features work correctly and that content remains usable as the site evolves. Evaluating a site with screen readers is the most reliable way to understand how users experience it. Combined with automated tools and manual checks, testing helps uncover issues that might otherwise go unnoticed, and and our how-to guide for inclusive user testing offers practical steps to get started.

Some effective testing approaches include:

  • Use real screen readers – Popular options include NVDA (Windows), VoiceOver (Mac), and JAWS. Each has slightly different behaviours, so trying more than one is valuable.

  • Navigate with a keyboard only – This mirrors how many people interact with assistive technology and helps identify focus or tab order issues.

  • Leverage automated testing tools – Tools like Axe or Lighthouse can highlight missing attributes or structural errors, though they should be supplemented with manual testing.

  • Test with actual users – Feedback from people who rely on screen readers provides insights no automated tool can replicate

The Benefits of a Well-Structured Website

Good structure supports every visitor, not just those using assistive technology. When content is organized clearly and coded correctly, websites become easier to navigate, faster to maintain, and more discoverable by search engines. For screen reader accessibility, strong structure ensures users can move through content efficiently and understand the relationships between different elements.

Key benefits include:

  • Improved usability – A logical reading order and clear headings make content easier to follow for everyone.

  • Better SEO – Semantic markup helps search engines understand page content, improving visibility and avoiding issues where accessibility impacts SEO.

  • Enhanced mobile experience – Clean structure supports smaller screens and voice-controlled browsing.

  • Easier maintenance – Consistent HTML reduces errors and simplifies updates.

Final Thoughts 

When websites are not designed with accessibility in mind, screen reader users face unnecessary barriers that make navigation and interaction difficult. Designers and developers need to think beyond visual layouts and commit to building content with semantic, meaningful structure.

An accessible website benefits everyone. It supports inclusion, improves search visibility, enhances mobile usability, and creates a better overall user experience. By prioritising accessibility from the start, businesses not only meet the needs of their audience but also strengthen their digital presence.

Is your website truly accessible? Now is the time to review its structure, address any gaps, and ensure it works for all users. Our Audits & Inclusive User Testing service can help you take that next step.

Similar posts

Discover how we’ve helped organisations overcome accessibility challenges and achieve success.

FAQs

Use semantic HTML, provide descriptive alt text for images, label all form fields, ensure headings follow a logical order, and make all interactive elements accessible by keyboard. Testing with assistive technology is also essential.

A screen reader processes the code behind a page and reads it aloud or outputs it to a braille display. It follows the underlying structure, moving through headings, links, lists, and landmarks in sequence.

Use tools like NVDA, JAWS, or VoiceOver to experience your site the way users do. Combine this with keyboard-only navigation and automated testing tools, and whenever possible, gather feedback from real users of assistive technology through our Digital Inclusion Lab.

They do not rely on visual layout cues such as menus on the left or banners at the top. Instead, navigation is done through headings, landmarks, and links announced in order by the screen reader.

The most common challenge is poor structure. Missing headings, unlabelled forms, and unclear navigation force users to listen through large amounts of content without context, slowing down the experience.

Website accessibility monitoring is the fundamental process of scanning your website to detect any issues that could prevent users with disabilities from using it. Automated web accessibility monitoring tools continuously check for accessibility issues across your site, providing instant alerts for new and updated content, as well as your overall site health.

 

They track compliance with standards like the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) and show you how accessible your site is, where it should be, and what improvements should be made to deliver a better experience for all users.

 

In addition to measuring your compliance, they also provide a clear picture of your progress over time, so you can track the impact of your improvements and maintain ongoing accessibility.

The two main types are automated and manual monitoring. Together, they provide you with a comprehensive view of how accessible your site is and where improvements are needed.

 

  • Automated monitoring uses specialised web accessibility monitoring tools to scan your website for non-compliant features and common issues, such as missing alt text, poor colour contrast, or keyword navigability issues. These tools can also provide instant alerts for when site elements present accessibility risks and site health reports so you can prioritise any issues.

  • Manual monitoring is where accessibility experts and testers come in to review your site as a real user would, often using assistive technologies like screen readers. They will usually check how easy it is to navigate through pages, interact with content, and understand messages or instructions. The aim is to identify any areas which may present barriers for individuals with disabilities.

Accessibility monitoring is crucial for ensuring that everyone can use and experience your site in the same way, regardless of ability. It is also essential for staying compliant with standards like WCAG and with laws like The European Accessibility Act 2025.

 

Without regular monitoring, accessibility issues can easily appear when new pages are added, content is updated, or designs are changed.

 

Continuous website accessibility monitoring gives you a framework to:

  • Stay compliant

  • Improve user experience

  • Respond to issues quickly

  • Track progress over time

Accessibility monitoring should be integrated into your process rather than a one-time check. Websites can change frequently, with new pages, designs, and content changes, but each update can introduce accessibility issues.

 

Continuous monitoring, both manual and through an automated website monitor, is recommended to catch any issues as soon as they appear, particularly after any big changes, such as adding interactive elements, redesigns, and when legal or accessibility guidelines are updated.

 

Even without significant changes, monitoring should be a consistent part of your organisations website maintenance.

 

The more you test the better, but for those looking for an exact amount, ideally once a month is a good starting point to catch any emerging issues.

Book a meeting

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Signup

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.